Silver replied: "In my opinion I think that Mercedes would be a sensible best buy. Mercs like those were built to last for a very long time. They are durable and will give you better fuel economy especially when compared with the Jeep. In regard to your mum saying you are stupid, you aren't because you chose a good first car. Unreliability is uncommon with these types of cars because they were built in the 92-93 era. It'll probably be more reliable than the Jeep. It's also classed as a sedan so although your insurance may be high, given your age, you will probably pay less than the Jeep, which is classed as a SUV. Maintenance can be expensive because the parts are usually sourced from Germany but a local reseller should have the parts readily available for this model. In terms of which is better, the Merc tops the Jeep in all aspects except off-road capability. If you will be using your car for off-road more than on road, only then would I recommend the Jeep. Honestly I'd go for the Merc because it's easier to handle as well. Especially if you're starting to drive, it's a great car to learn on. However, insist on a full service history and get the car checked out by a qualified mechanic. If he spots any parts in bad condition, you can negotiate with the seller to reduce the selling price or replace it. This will save you major money in the long run and make you aware of any problems the car may have before you purchase it. The check up may be expensive but considering the amount you may possibly save due to it, it far outweighs the check up price. Another plus of the Merc is that if it has good mileage on it, the fuel economy is stable and the engine has been run in well. I'd say your mum isn't right because she isn't giving you an alternative (or you haven't stated one). All in all the Merc would be your best choice especially over the Jeep. Good luck on your purchase and I do hope I have helped you in this regard."